Tag Archives berlin

Overflowing emotions. Blame Fidelio

Overflowing emotions. Blame Fidelio

Posted on

It’s taken me exactly 9 days to fall in love with Berlin. And when you consider that I was only there for 10 days, that was cutting it pretty fine.

The reason?

This was the reason:

These are two scenes of the excellently executed Beethoven’s Fidelio opera. As you can probably tell, it has been produced with a completely modern twist to it; unlike “traditional” operas where the performers wear period pieces and the whole ambiance is of a bygone age, the Komische Oper Berlin Fidelio’s production has had some modern elements inserted in it from props to method to I suspect the way its treated.

It was doubly more pleasurable for both my friend Tolkun Umaraliev and I as our seats were front and middle. On the first row. I swear that sometimes we could both feel the music and the voices reverberating in our chests, especially when the stage filled with over 100 singers some of whom came down from the stage and performed right in front of us, about a foot or so away!

And although the opera is in German, we could follow the dialogue quite well, no, not because we suddenly became fluent in German, but the opera seats had small LED screens built into them where the subtitles are displayed in synch with the voices! What a brilliant invention! I must confess that although I peeked at the translation once in a while, it wasn’t really necessary as you can follow the excellently expressive performances and get the gist of the story quite readily.

It was a very emotional experience for both of us. It was fantastic, easily one of the most memorable moments of my life and one that I would love to share with my wife. Gives me an excuse for another lightening quick trip out of Bahrain, and soon!

Share

Lessons in Citizenship

Posted on
School children listening to the Speaker of the German Government

Yesterday was a full day with us starting with a visit to Der Tagesspiegel and chatting with its editor responsible for both online and print media and then to the Bundespressekonferenz to listen to about a dozen ministerial spokespersons, who each in turn presented the latest news from their ministry and fielded questions from the audience.

As special guests at the Bundespressekonferenz, we were also joined by a class of young German students. Both our groups were invited to stay after the official part of the conference was done, and then listened to and questioned the government spokesman Ulrich Wilhelm.

The Bundespressekonferenz is an NGO created by journalists just after the 2nd World War. Its members are invited to listen to the government programs presented by the invited government representatives and are given the opportunity to ask questions during these fixed meetings which occur every Monday, Wednesday and Friday. Guests are permitted but are not allowed to ask questions. It’s held in a building directly opposite the parliament.

What impressed me most about this event is not only the presence of German youth, but the special attention given to them – they were especially welcomed by the chairman of the session and recognised – but also the time the government official took to address them, talk to them about the current issues discussed at that session and answered their questions.

This, to my mind, served two very important purposes: [1] it demonstrated the transparency of the government, and most importantly [2] without having the youth waving German flags and carrying pictures of their PM, they were given a very subtle and much more effective lesson in citizenship; one that will be deeply ingrained and doesn’t require overt and most of the time excessive demonstration of forced loyalty to ones country.

I’m starting to love Germany…

Share

Postcards from Berlin – 1

Posted on

Berlin’s way of remembering the past to ensure that history doesn’t repeat itself while honoring those who made sacrifices in the country’s turbulent history.

Share

Sheep and lions

Posted on
Protest

Protest, originally uploaded by malyousif.

I don’t know the presumably homeless person’s story, and I don’t know if it’s him who wrote that fantastic expression on the wall. But I can’t help wondering if his choice of position and state are the translation of that expression.

If it is, then at least I hope that whoever he has a beef with will at least pass by and read what’s on the wall:

Better to be a lion for a day than spend your life as a sheep

Share

Healing and Reconciliation

Posted on

Humble Berlin.

Although still smarting from past wrongs, it doesn’t choose to bury its head in the sand and pretend nothing happened over half a century ago.

No.

The Stasi Archives. There are about 20 rooms filled to the brim with some 18 million records just in Berlin.
It instead found the bravery and humility required to open deep wounds, clean them up, come to terms with history and use those painful experiences to ensure that those horrible events never recur.

Unlike us, they didn’t simply promulgate a law pardoning the torturers and tortured, much to our disgust and international disbelief. They didn’t throw away the chance to a much needed national reconciliation.

No.

They took a single step amongst many by gathering all the records left behind their erstwhile State Secret Police and preserved them into an archive containing some 18 million records, and gave their citizens the opportunity to view the content of their files, should they exist. That offered a lot of people the required closure and allowed them to heal and move on with their lives.

That was one brave step toward national reconciliation.

Reconciliation as a concept is easy of course. But its implementation requires real courage. Something I’m sad to say doesn’t seem to exist in our lovely little country.

Will there be anyone brave enough to tread that path for a better future?

Share

Ah, Germany is not that free after all!

Ah, Germany is not that free after all!

I know, such a revaluation isn’t it?

I’m in Berlin as part of an excellent program by the German Federal Foreign Office. They invited a group of 15 international bloggers coming from countries spanning across from Costa Rica through to China. Part of the program is to meet with German bloggers and opinion makers to effect a cultural exchange of sorts. The program is not strenuous at all, not like the usual conferences and workshops I usually go to which cram a lifetime into 3 days. With those you invariably come out fullfilled to be sure, but completely sapped and exhausted too. Well this one is different on many levels. It’s spread over 10 full days with planned time-outs and cultural visits too. Yes, it’s a holiday with a purpose. Thank you Germany 🙂

Blogger Tour 13 May – 22 May 2010 List of participants

Mrs Eman Al‐Nafjan
saudiwoman.wordpress.com
Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

Mr Mahmood Al Yousif
mahmood.tv
Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain

Mr Markus Balsiger
www.wahlkampfblog.ch
Bern, Swiss Confederation

Mr Cristian Cambronero
www.fusildechispas.com
San José, Republic of Costa Rica

Mr Miloš Čermák
cermak.blog.respekt.cz
Prague, Czech Republic

Mr Ato Kwamena Dadzie
www.atokd.com
Accra, Republic of Ghana

Miss Nigar Fatali
fatalin.wordpress.com
Baku, Republic of Azerbaijan

Mr Elia Kabanov
metkere.com/en
Novosibirsk, Russian Federation

Mr Andrew Loh
www.theonlinecitizen.com
Singapore, Republic of Singapore

Mr Nino Raspudić
blog.vecernji.hr/nino-raspudic
Zagreb, Republic of Croatia

Mr Mahmoud Salem
www.sandmonkey.org
Cairo, Arab Republic of Egypt

Mr Aliyu Usman Tilde
fridaydiscourse.blogspot.com
Abuja, Federal Republic of Nigeria

Mr Árpád Tóta
w.blog.hu
Budapest, Republic of Hungary

Mr Tulkinjon Umaraliev
www.tolkun.info
Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic

Mr Michael Anti
blog.sina.com.cn/anti
Beijing, People’s Republic of China

We concluded the first day of the program yesterday where we listened to 4 excelent people talk about the German blogosphere, politics, laws and media environment. The one i felt most important was a presentation by a self-described “aggressive lawyer” whose daily job, again by his own description, is to aggressively go after bloggers! It’s ironic because he himself is a blogger too.

Yes, lawyers are supposed to be dry – and the first glance at this one’s text-filled slides sort of confirmed that adage. I know that my fellow bloggers were at first skeptical too. We were resigned to what we were about to receive wouldn’t be anything better than Death by PowerPoint. That mode – i could see around me – was fully engaged.

But the guy surprised us. He didn’t only know how to press our buttons, he was also lucid in his thoughts, methodical in his presentation and made the relatively dry subject of Internet & Press Freedoms interesting through his evident passion.

The gist of his presentation is this: be prepared to be sued if you libel anyone, and he (and other lawyers too) will come after you!

In German law, there is no distinction between a traditional journalist and a “pro” blogger; that is, if your content is “news-type” approaching the same standards as that of a traditional mainstream paper, then you’re not only regarded as an equal to a journalist, but also will be deemed to have met the prerequisites of enrollment in a journalist union and will have the same rights and responsibilities enjoyed by journalists.

Weird isn’t it? And some still choose to be nit-picky about what pigeon hole bloggers should reside in! My friends, the lines are most certainly blurred and there isn’t a pigeon hole big enough to stuff bloggers in.

German law also provides no distinction between slander and libel and guarantees both freedom of expression and the freedom of the press.

Article 5 of the German Constitution (Basic Law) states:

Every person shall have the right freely to express and disseminate his opinions in speech, writing, and pictures and to inform himself without the hindrance from generally accessible sources. Freedom of the press and freedom of reporting by means of broadcasts and films shall be guaranteed. There shall be no censorship.

These freedoms are further backed up by several other basic rights such as the guarantee of private property and the right to freely choose and exercise any profession.

It also emphasises that all citizens are generally free to run a publishing company or offer opinions – critical or otherwise – and information in any form to the public by starting a blog – for example – without any kind of governmental approval.

The proviso is that one has to be conscious of the limits of freedom, that is, one’s freedom ends where another’s begin.

This is taken to levels which could be considered by others as extremes; for instance, one has the full right to walk in the street, any street in Germany, fully naked! Regardless of gender. And no one can force that person to dress-up because they individually think that that behavior is “unsavoury” or “disgraceful”, that – I suspect – is an individual’s opinion which is open to interpretation. However, if someone complains that a person’s nakedness “disturbs” him, than and only then would it be considered as impinging on that person’s freedom and the naked person is made to dress up.

The press in Germany is independent of governmental control to the extent that governments (there are 16 of them in this Federation) are forbidden to issue or get involved in the issuance of Press Cards as those are solely the responsibility of the professional bodies such as Press Unions.

Herr Jon Mönikes, the vigorously aggressive lawyer warns us though, that you have to stand behind your words. In what to my mind is a contradictory and unconstitutional requirement, he says that publishers must declare their names and addresses on their blogs, this is to demonstrate responsibility in allowing people easy access to communicate with them should they need to, and for the lawyers to know where to send the summons or the law suit to! Doesn’t that contradict with the Constitutionality of anyone is allowed to have a publishing company, let alone a blog, and not to have to register it with the government? Thinking about it now, I don’t think so and it makes sense. A publisher must stand by his publication. However I’m unsure that this condition is a government requirement, I suspect it’s not but is required possibly by the Unions.

Upon notification from his clients of an infringement in a blog or any other type of media, Herr Mönikes investigates the situation and if there is merit he would lift the phone to talk to the publication’s owner and demand the alteration, removal or retraction of whatever is published. If they choose not to, he takes them to court, something he proudly states that he has done hundreds if times. And here in Germany, the loser in any civil court must pay the lawyer’s and court fees for the case, so it could get very expensive, especially for bloggers. Most, of course, comply.

Publishers are ultimately responsible for whatever is published on their blogs. Even comments! Yes, that was a revelation to me and a lot of my fellow bloggers in the room. But, there are limits of course… If you do not exercise moderation, that is, if you don’t approve the comment before it is displayed on your blog, then you are not responsible. However, the government or the lawyer has the right to force you to declare the commenter’s identity and IP address if available! That seriously freaked me out!

The advice? Well, don’t read the comments! But if you do and if you find that the comment might warrant a case against you, then you are beholden by law to remove it! If you don’t, then get prepared to be dragged into court. When notified, “professional” bloggers must remove the offending material within something like 24 hours of notification, amateurs however get quite a bit more leeway and get to remove it in a week or so, and of course, as theirs is not professional, then the roles and responsibilities assigned to journalists do not apply to them.

Article 5 continues to say:

  • These rights shall find their limits in the provisions of general laws, in provisions for the protection of young persons, and in the right to personal honour.
  • Accordingly, limis to the freedom of expression are:
    • general laws (including opposing constitutional rights of third parties) – general laws are federal and supersede local governments laws
    • youth protection – child pornography, certain types of violence depictions, etc
    • right to personal honour – libel, slander, etc

    Probably the only no-negotiation law in Germany which even supersedes freedoms of expression is Holocaust Denial. Germans take this very seriously and if you do, then off to prison you go at the happy expense of the German government and citizens for 5 years. Full Stop.

    So don’t deny the Holocaust happening and don’t display swastikas and other Nazi symbols. And oh, you can’t sell Mein Kampf here either. You can own it if it’s handed to you or you found it, but you cannot sell it, and by inference, you won’t be able to buy it.

    Regarding the Holocaust, you CAN question its situation, the numbers involved and do academic research into it, but you just cannot deny it’s occurrence.

    So how is this all different from the laws in Bahrain and other Arab countries? It seems even stricter than what is coded in our own countries.

    Thinking about these issues since yesterday, I think the differences are quite apparent. While in Germany (and other democracies) the law is applied fairly, it is backed up by an independent judiciary and above all it is applied with good will. With us, unfortunately, regardless of how good the laws are on paper, they are applied with ill will for the most part, with an eye on a hidden or declared agenda.

    Will this situation change in the future? I hope so. But it won’t happen on its own accord. It requires people to stand up and vigorously demand their rights, rather than just be the usual acquiescents we normally are.

    Share

    Suicide note?

    Posted on
    Suicide note?

    Suicide note?, originally uploaded by malyousif.

    I didn’t notice this sticker on my hotel window before I heard a scream and a body passing my window which is on the 13th floor of the hotel overlooking the Alexanderplatz.

    Imagine my shock when I discovered that it wasn’t a suicide that I had just witnessed, but a bloody "Base Flyer" or "Sky Jumper" or whatever you want to call those "adventurers" who choose to hurtle down 125 meters to the lower deck past scared people’s windows!

    Share

    Doner Kebab

    Posted on
    Doner Kebab

    Doner Kebab, originally uploaded by malyousif.

    There goes the diet!

    Couldn’t help myself grabbing one from the first shop I came across selling it outside the hotel.

    I must admit that it’s not as good as I remembered it from Frankfurt, and nowhere close to the one I had in Amsterdam.

    But it did fill a hole…

    Share